Coach Lindsay was a three year letter winner on the hardwood for Olathe South High School. In his senior season, he was the Falcons second leading scorer and the team’s leader in rebounding. Lindsay was a Second Team All-Sunflower League selection, earned All-Olathe Honors, and was named Honorable Mention Kansas 6A State by the Wichita Eagle and the Topeka Capital Journal. He helped the Falcons to a Sunflower League Tri-Championship with an overall record of 18-3. During his senior season, Lindsay averaged 12 points, five rebounds and two assists per game.

In his first collegiate season, Lindsay appeared in 30 games and made 18 starts for the Braves. He averaged eight points and four rebounds per game. Lindsay shot 45 percent from the floor, 44 percent from behind the 3-pt line, and 75 percent from the free throw line. Because of his play on the court, Lindsay was named to the KCAC Freshman Team. He scored a career high 22 points versus the University of Saint Mary in the KCAC Tournament Semifinals. Lindsay scored his first point, grabbed his first collegiate rebound, and started his first collegiate game against Avila University. He scored in double figures eight times and averaged 15.2 points per game in his final four games of the season. Lindsay earned his first career double-double with 12 points and a career high 10 rebounds versus McPherson College. He was a perfect 4-for-4 from behind the three point line versus the University of Saint Mary.

Lindsay appeared in 30 games as a sophomore for the Braves. He was named to the 2012-13 All-KCAC Defensive team. Lindsay averaged 8.2 points and 4.5 rebounds per game. Lindsay scored in double figures 11 times with a season high 20 points and a career high six assists against Bethel College. He attempted a career high 15 shots against Southwestern College and made a career high 70 percent of his shots against Bethel College.